Monday, February 22, 2010

Secession: Getting it right this time

Jonathan M. Kolkey at LewRockwell.com thinks that the word "secession" is inappropriate to our current situation. For one thing, the word is too emotionally charged from the War between the States. He suggests "partition", because it suggests a win-win solution -- the South can preserve its culture, New England and California can try out their Americanized European welfare state, and Ohio can rebuild its economy free of federal baggage.

So contemporary Secessionists will only succeed fully when they garner widespread political and geographic support and avoid close association with any particular party or ideology. Therefore, any Secession movement must pay as much attention to the North as to the South and West. And rather than wasting time blasting the "Puritan" North as the source of all American dysfunction – as at least one LewRockwell.com contributor routinely does – would-be Secessionists must devote all their energy to convincing Northerners that Secession is also very much in their own best interest.

In truth, the Blue-state folks also favor the dismantling of the Union – they just don’t know it yet. Indeed many Blue staters speak wistfully of an American version of a European-style secular social democracy that would arise eventually once the South leaves. But they have no concrete plans for any disconnection. (So in the absence of any such plans, why not supply them?) Be sure to make Blue Staters willing accomplices or "co-conspirators," if you will.

Of course, at present the North has too much invested in the Union victory of 1865 and everything that followed accordingly, especially the Civil Rights’ crusade of the 1960s. The North is loath to abandon its heroic triumphs over Southern "barbarism." In fact, it would be better for the Secession movement to drop the term "Secession" itself in favor of "partition" – a less historically-charged word that denotes a clean break from which both sides presumably benefit.


Sounds good to me, but then I'm for anything that will help us regain our lost freedom.

No comments: